Reading Carl Sandburg’s American Songbag

I spent much of today reading through Carl Sandburg’s landmark 1927 folk song collection American Songbag,  all 500-plus-pages of it. It’s not the first time I’ve looked into the book, and indeed I’ve paged through it or jumped to songs I was interested in before. But next month I’m planning a trip to Sandburg’s boyhood home in Illinois and to Iowa City where I will be taking a look at some papers relating to early 20th century poet and professor Edwin Ford Piper who was one of the sources of folk song material used in Sanburg’s anthology.*  So, looking at the book in full seemed a good grounding for this trip.

I’ve made the case before here, such as this post from a year ago, that besides being a somewhat deemphasized Modernist poet these days, Sandburg is a primary model for the American Folk Music Revival, which eventually produced in the second half of the 20th century several genres of popular and semi-popular music.**  Here’s the matrix that Sandburg built in the 1920s, a hundred years ago:

  • American folk music can be appreciated like art music
  • It will be associated with literary poetry
  • It expresses, or can be adapted to express or accompany, progressive/left-wing causes
  • It’s multi-ethnic, and the contribution of Afro-Americans will be substantially acknowledged
  • Humor and funny stories will be part of its presentation

Sandburg was including segments of folk music performance as part of poetry readings before American Songbag.  AFAIK we don’t have any transcripts or recordings from that era, but all these things are demonstrated for the record in the 1927 book. Sandburg is not the only American doing any of these things a hundred years ago, but he’s doing all of them at once,  and he’s doing it with a degree of fame and cultural acclaim that was significant.

I was aided in my rapid march through American Songbag  by already knowing many of the songs it contains, and as I encountered them I remembered hearing them in my half of the 20th century performed by Woody Guthrie, Pete Seeger, Bob Dylan and many of those other “folk singers” that surrounded them.***  The Sing Out magazine and Jerry Silverman folk songbooks of the Sixties that are my foundation, are successors to Sandburg’s work, right down to the touch of  using vintage B&W line drawings as interspersed decorations.

Sandburg often includes little stories about the collector (Piper was one of a group who collected the songs “in the field” for Songbag)  and for those he collected himself he says a few words about how, where, and with whom he first heard the song. Here’s one of the most engaging of those stories I came upon today in the book:

Once when the night was wild without and the wintry winds piled snowdrifts around the traffic signals on Cottage Grove Avenue, Chicago, we sat with Robert Frost and Padraic Colum. The Gael had favored with Irish ballads of murder, robbery, passion. And Frost offered a sailorman song he learned as a boy on the wharves of San Francisco.

The song Frost sang for Colum and Sandburg? A subtle wry ballad of farming? A nuanced lyric of nature cooly observed? No, it was this one. Some will know it from its latter association with the Assassin’s Creed video game franchise:

.

*Besides the folks songs Piper contributes, Sandburg even quotes a part of a poem from his contemporary Piper’s Barb Wire  poetry collection in Songbag.

**Besides the Folk Scare of the 50s and 60s, the American “Rock Music” that extended Rock’n’Roll to FM radio, college campuses, and rock critics was generally formed from folks who had connections with the just preceding folk revival. Modern Americana and roots music links to the same strains and connections that Sandburg was personifying 100 years ago.

***Guthrie composed music for Sanburg poems later. Ruth Crawford Seeger (Pete’s step-mom, Mike and Peggy Seeger’s birth mother) was one of the composers who created harmonized music for the folk songs in Songbag,  and she also set Sandburg’s page poems to music. When the young Bob Dylan started to expand the poeticism of his song lyrics, he decided to pay a visit to Sandburg, briefly meeting him unannounced in North Carolina at Sandburg’s farm. Other folk luminaries connected? At least a couple songs collected from Leadbelly by John Lomax are included in Songbag.  Lomax is credited, but Leadbelly isn’t, though Leadbelly’s more general public career hadn’t yet started. Let me just say that Lomax’s relationship with Leadbelly is complicated. Just this month I was reading a recollection of a performance by Spider John Koerner (who first performed in the mid-century Minneapolis folk music scene along with Dylan) where he told a humorous story about a farmer who fed his pig by lifting him up to the branches of an apple tree. That’s a story Sandburg also told. I’ll also note that when I came upon several songs in Songbag,  the rendition I recalled from the Folk Scare of the mid-century was by Dave Van Ronk, a wonderful performer and a mentor to Dylan when he arrived in New York.

2 thoughts on “Reading Carl Sandburg’s American Songbag

  1. It so good to see there’s a Wikipedia article on Edwin Ford Piper now. Thank you!

    Some Piper things I’m seeking to flesh out are from long thread from X/Twitter a couple of years back that I’ve just recently read. There’s a linked article at the start of the thread by the thread’s author (an active SF author) about the rise of “Workshop” networking and how its associated method of teaching creative writing started at the famed Iowa Writer’s Workshop.

    https://x.com/sl_huang/status/1560351769951191043

    The author has some interesting points about workshops, Paul Engle, and all that, but with my interest in Edwin Ford Piper two things the thread author mentions in passing interest me particularly.

    1. That the very first workshop with a circle of students reading and then critiquing works in progress was in a class lead by Piper. Was he just a random test case for a pedagogy someone else wanted to try or was this format his idea? If it was his idea, a great many writers of my generation experienced this format around the US in their own creative writing classes/workshops/groups.
    2. That Piper’s wife thought that “politics” stressed Piper to an early death. If forced to guess I think faculty politics, as many universities are famous for that sort of conflict, but it wouldn’t be shocking if it might politics politics, given the 1930s was an era with noteable literary disputes based on political stances taken by writers. I have no idea what Piper’s political leanings were.

    There must be books on the rise of Paul Engle and Iowa Writer’s Workshop. I may have to look for that to find out more about Piper’s later years.

    The only picture I have of Edwin Ford Piper was that drawing that I grabbed from a short video and posted here: https://frankhudson.org/2024/03/06/the-last-antelope/

    Can’t be sure of its Public Domain status though.

    ——————————————————-

    ****UPDATE****

    Burnt some midnight oil after typing these questions, getting partway to some answers. Piper did lead small student workshops before the officially listed start of the Iowa Writers Workshop (in 1936) and does seem to be present in it at that program’s start date as well.* Official history has Wilbur Schramm as the initial Director of the Iowa Writer’s Workshop. Schramm is a fascinating character, a polymath, and Schramm started pioneering schools at more than one university for Creative Writing, Journalism, and what he called “Communications” which included more than just PR but theories about communications works. On the other hand, I have an article** quoting him recalling to Paul Engle in 1976 “When he [Piper] died suddenly of a heart attack, [In 1939] I had to take over. They should probably have gotten someone else at that time, and I rather expected them to, but I had a little while when no one else was there, and so had a lot of fun doing what I thought needed doing”

    Even given the vagaries of memory that’s odd. The IWW current official history says Schramm was the first director and it started in 1936. Schramm talking the famous director Engle (also present at the University of Iowa at this time) seems to say that no, three years later he (Schramm) is sort of “drafted” to fill the post following Piper’s death.

    U of Iowa does claim to be the first to have a degree-granting program for creative writing. Schramm seems like the kind of theorist who might have helped formulate the pedagogy, and he moved about acting as a sort of Johnny Appleseed for teaching writing at the college level as a distinct degree-granting program. That theory doesn’t eliminate Piper or pre-existing practice in workshops before The Workshop from having input into that eventual ubiquitous format.

    *https://pubs.lib.uiowa.edu/palimpsest/article/id/21621/download/pdf/

    **https://catdir.loc.gov/catdir/samples/simon052/93043281.html

    Like

Leave a comment