Alternative Music

The Wind Began to Rock

~ Frank Hudson ~ 1 Comment

Someone on social media this week suggested this conversational opener: “Remember when talking about the weather was just small talk?”

I was thinking about this as I worked to finish today’s musical piece that I’d started a week ago. Since then, American news has been filled with accounts of one major hurricane’s aftermath and the approach of another one. The kind of fun I have meshing poetry with a variety of music I compose and realize is hard to set beside disasters of this scope. I think: here I am privileged to explore unusual connections when other citizens are dealing with hardship and immense losses. In the end I saw the Dickinson poem speaking to those differing situations, and I’ll finish by talking about making this musical piece and the style of its playing which also lets two strong differences coexist.

“The Wind Began to Rock”  presents as a narrative, with well observed descriptions of the storm’s arrival and then deluge, but Dickinson chooses the odd conclusion. You can read the text of her poem here.  We don’t get a tale of devastation. We don’t get the following suffering. We’ve had the fury — and then what? The incongruity of that ending — if it isn’t a mistake, what is it? I think we should be convinced of Dickinson’s genius enough to make our default assumption it’s written with intent. I’m already risking insensitivity, could I add humor to this and say that with the anti-climactic ending of the narrative arc here, I could have appended a subtitle “Started early, took my shaggy dog.”

I’ll just briefly note that Dickinson could be writing from experience. During the 1861 hurricane season, her hometown of Amherst got the inland tail-end of two storms. But I’ll note another metaphoric storm too at the same time: America’s Civil War. That this huge storm occurs, and the Dickinson household damage reported at the end is only “quartering a tree” may be her point.   Some are losing more, up to their lives. The question of enslavement’s onerous human property and the continued existence of the nation that her father served in the Congress of are at risk.

Even the seemingly inconsequential summary of “quartering a tree” is an odd choice that bears consideration. Is this a reference to the particularly cruel execution practice of “drawing and quartering?”

The storm has not made her  house divided and not standing, but the tree may say her privileged situation has a crucifix of more complete suffering in view. Questions may arise to us, if we are privileged to not be in the direct path of hurricanes or oppression, looking out on our own storm season and the drifting path to an election this Autumn. All those thoughts arose after I’d completed the recording of today’s musical piece. My earlier performance was innocent of them, but let me present the music anyway.

As I mentioned last time, Emily Dickinson’s wide-ranging poetic spirit had possessed me with this charge: “I wanna rock!” I have no idea how rocking Dickinson’s own parlor-piano music-making was, but her poetry often indicates to me a mood of loud slyness that could front a rock band.

Rock music famously doesn’t require a lot of compositional undergirding, and the harmonic framework of the music here was minimal: two chords (B and A), their roots a full-step apart. Yet, it really doesn’t correspond with typical chordal cadences in Blues or Rock — it’s a tactic I associate with the Velvet Underground, a smart people in a rock band collective whose formative association once traded under the name “The Primitives.”

VU with ED2

Today’s musical piece doesn’t sound much like this band, but “All Tomorrow’s Hurricanes” was a cut on the first Velvet Underground and Emily Dickinson album. Andy Warhol’s cover had a picture of a peelable ghost flower.

.

As much as I was working with piano, bowed strings, and acoustic guitar lately, I was itching to get back to loud electric guitar — but my situation in this era of my life makes two poles of music making more difficult to schedule. My quiet stuff has to be recorded when outside noise won’t scrape and bark into sensitive microphones, and the loud Rock that asks for interaction between the electric guitars and amplifiers pushing rude airwaves into a room risks disturbing others. Sometimes the situation, that I can’t whisper in an otherwise silent room, only makes me want to turn up the electric guitars all the more.

As you’ll hear if you venture to the audio player below, I was able to turn the guitar amps up for this, though I had a limited window to shatter.

The kind of guitar playing that steps out to the lead in the ensemble today is a style I worked with quite a bit back at the turn of the century. Like the chord progression, it’s not Rock-band-conventional. The framework is two lead guitars each free to explore melodic lines without strictly alternating (e.g. obligatory “call and response,” “trading fours,” or the like) or playing pre-composed harmonic intervals between their melody notes. It’s still Rock-music-like in that the two lead instruments reference the Rock beat, but this kind of simultaneous, spontaneous lead playing happens only rarely in the Rock genre. You can hear something like it in some folk musics, in early Jazz, and much later in Free Jazz — but for all its “let’s make a racket” ethos, Rock music generally avoids this.

Anyway, if you want to listen to this as it’s intended to be heard, don’t use ear buds or quiet levels. Use a set of stereo speakers and turn up the volume level. You can dance if you want to.

Audio player washed out on your way to reading this?  This highlighted link is an alternative that will open a new tab with its own audio player.

.

In a Station of the Metro

~ Frank Hudson ~ Leave a comment

As we were going to school this morning, my son and I were listening to reports from the South by Southwest event in Austin this week. The guy on the radio was explaining that while SXSW has broadened over the years, it’s still the place to go for Alternative Music.

“I wonder where you go if you’re looking for an alternative to Alternative Music?” I asked out-loud. Not the most original thought, but I’ve never liked labels even though we all use them.

My son—who’s reminded me for several years now that he is not a Millennial—replied “Well, I only listen to lowercase!”

Proud of that boy.

Well of course, Alternative Music or Indie music, or whatever you call it isn’t really a Millennial thing. It’s more of an outgrowth of Generation X* in the last century. And that in itself was just the next name stuck on whatever Dave and I were doing 40 years ago when someone thought Punk was the label. And then, scratch-off the sticky paper from a Punk from those days and most likely you’d find someone who was once a young Hippie. And Hippies were just kids that Beats thought hadn’t wised up yet.

I don’t know all that much of what Ezra Pound thought of the Beats, but I recall in the 1950s Allen Ginsberg wrote Pound in St. Elizabeth’s hospital where he was serving his commitment as crazy, the alternative to his prison cage for WWII treason.**  Ginsberg later met him in 1967 and Pound sorta-kinda apologized for the—you know, anti-Semitism and stuff.

But back in 1913, before either world war, Pound was trying to figure out modern poetry in English. If it would be, what it should be. He had some materials to reuse: medieval vernacular poetry, classical Chinese and Japanese poetry, some of the modern French poets, and he wasn’t the only smith at the poetry-forge either, Brits T. E. Hulme and F. S. Flint were working at this too.

Late 19th Century English poetry tended to be enwrought in the cloths of heaven, lofty abstract metaphors and repetitions of what were considered the usual Romantic poetic sentiments. Those poems sounded poetic, sure, but were they? But if so much of that was thrown out, what would be left, what could replace that?

In such a mood, in such preparation, Ezra Pound stepped out of a subway station in Paris. Something in the urban crowd he saw there struck him and he wrote a modest 30-line poem that is unknown to you and me. Pound did not like his 30-line poem. It may have sounded poetic, it may have looked poetic, but it seemed false. He wrung out the false and the result was two lines, the famous Imagist poem “In a Station of the Metro”  that begins “The apparition of these faces…”

Young Ezra Pound bundled up

Ah dude, nice marmot! The young Ezra Pound

 

I’ve used an excerpt of an account that Pound published three years later about his experience and aims in creating “In a Station of the Metro”  to begin today’s audio piece. I sometimes think of Pound as gruff, inward looking, full of unusual words and quotes from various languages I do not speak, a portrayal of a learned hermit that both of us want to leave alone. But if I’m to take him at his word as he tells this story, he is the transit-riding 20-something Pound, struck by ordinary daily beauty and not wanting to betray it with ordinary poetry.

What do the 14 words of “In a Station of the Metro”  tell us? It’s spring—for tree blossoms, like Meng Haoran’s famous short Chinese poem, are the central image. Perhaps there’s been a rain-shower while Pound was in the subway. He climbs up the stairs and unexpectedly the faces in the street are not cast down out of the no-longer rain. Perhaps the sun is peeking through. They are beautiful without saying, as blossom flowers are. As blossom flowers are, some would have been knocked down by rain, some nourished, and none will be even spring-forever.

To hear my performance of Pound’s account of how he came to write it, followed by the poem itself, use the player below.

 

 

 

*Has anyone fully blamed Billy Idol for that name? Idol claims he took his first band’s name from a 1950s book, but conceptually I’ve always wondered if Richard Hell and his song “Blank Generation”  was the fountainhead.

**Pound had remained in Italy where he had settled before WWII. Enamored of various esoteric theories he thought congruent with Italian Fascism, he recorded radio broadcasts which were characterized as propaganda for the enemy during the war. Captured after the fall of Mussolini, he was at first imprisoned as a traitor in an outdoor cage.